Saturday, July 6, 2013

Building Up or Building Out

The most common category of complaints that I hear about cities is regarding crowding vs. spread. Some cities like New York seem just too tightly packed while others like Los Angeles spread across vast distances and become extremely inefficient. These are two extremes, but cities tend to fall all along this spectrum and rarely do cities seem to achieve perfect balance.

So which is better? Build massive skyscrapers in a tiny area thereby crowding streets with pedestrians and blocking sun from roads or designate hundreds of square miles for sprawling cities where most builds are detached and less than four or five stories tall? Let's start by examining the issue with both types of cities.

Hong Kong
Hong Kong can easily be designated as a crowding city. The population density is about 16,500 per square mile. To put this in perspective, the average population density across the United States is 88 per square mile. Notice in this picture of Hong Kong, almost all construction is in the form of skyscrapers. Looking out of a window you are very likely to be looking into an adjacent building rather than into the sky. Despite the fact that the city is so built up, not all land is used. The higher elevations around the corners of the photo are virtually undeveloped.

Los Angeles
Los Angeles on the other hand can be seen as a city of sprawl. It is still tightly packed, but because of the low density development, the population density is about 8,000 per square mile. At this level there is plenty of open space, but travelling from place to place can be a nightmare. Cities with such a spread cannot support the vast public transit systems of more dense cities and car traffic can overwhelm the roadways as a result.

Both types of cities have clear problems and may seek to emulate the other type of city. It is relatively challenging for cities to achieve a balance between the two extremes and I do not have a perfect solution to these problems.

My favorite ideal solution is one that I so far have not found in any city. I envision a city with a medium / high density residential urban core, something where the buildings average perhaps 15 stories. Within this central area, cars would not be allowed and so all roadways would be fully open to pedestrians. These walkways would be wide so that the sun would never be blocked by shadows. Around the residential core would be three or four separate downtown areas that are high density. Each of these clusters of downtown would be grouped by industry; for example, one cluster may include banks and financial services while another may be pharmaceutical and biotech companies. Essentially this city would look like a bowl from the sky. This may seem a strange idea, but I would like to see it put in place as an experiment.


Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, June 22, 2013

Strip Malls vs. Starbucks

Some of the most beautiful cities in the world are those that seem to have a soul. Some of these cities, like Boston, make the cut because they have a disorganized charm while others such as Shanghai are known for the modern feel. Regardless of what makes a particular city special, the thing that my favorite places have in common is that they are all unique and have something that cannot be mimicked by another place.

This for example is a picture that captures the essence of Shanghai.

It appears to me that at some point, cities and to a greater extend suburbs forgot what it meant to have a unique feeling. In came developers. Sprawling neighborhoods emerged of houses that not only looked the same as one another, but looked the same as others in other towns and even in other parts of the country. This is not limited to residential development; strip malls and chain restaurants populate huge tracts of land. Standing in one of these malls one would have no way of guessing if they were in Florida or North Dakota, except maybe for the temperature!

True it may be cheaper and easier to build standardized developments, but it also takes the heart out of an area. The appeal of an area is lessened as it imitates the style of everywhere else. This type of development can drain the life out of a city.

While this trend seems to roll along, some retail companies have notably bucked the trend. My two best examples of this are Apple and Starbucks. When visiting a location of one of these stores, you know that you are sitting and drinking your favorite coffee or shopping for a nice computer, but you also know where you are. These stores are built to represent the feel of the company while respecting the environment that they are found in. Apple has been able to build stores inside of the Louvre and Grand Central Station. These locations represent a fantastic balance between standards of design and urban cultural awareness that other new developments should seek to emulate. 

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Washington D.C. : America's Best City For Young People

The morning sun passes through the large windows of the mid-rise apartment, no taller buildings cast shadows onto the facade or into the wide streets of the city. Looking out from almost any point, one can see the impressive structure emblematic of a vibrant history. People stop by their local cafes, passing briefly en route to their jobs, wearing suits that live up to the grandeur of the buildings in which they work. This is a snapshot of life in Washington D.C.


While it goes without saying that life in Washington D.C. is not perfect by any measure, the city has so much to offer, particularly for people in their 20s. Over the past 20 years the city has grown rapidly and a lot of this growth has come from young age groups. The median age of city residents is 33, compared to almost 40 nationwide. This rapid growth has increased real estate prices, but it has also brought many new amenities and services to the city. 

Because the federal government is located within the city, unemployment rates are notoriously low, currently are 5.3%. The government provides stable jobs through almost any economic climate so residents of the city tend to have great employment prospects. The federal government is also known as being one of the best places to work; employees get much better benefits than employees at most private companies. 

Despite being so big, the city is so well planned in its design that it truly feels like an eclectic city of neighborhoods. No two areas of the city are quite the same and almost the entire city is composed of medium density development. Walking around the city, one can feel the culture shift every few blocks. The city feels much more European than any other American city. The development pattern is a bit less efficient than highly developed citys like New York, but it is much more aesthetically appealing. 

D.C. also has a wide array of choices for entertainment. The city is full of clubs, bars, restaurants and music venues of all different types. No matter what your preference, you can likely find your niche in D.C. To bolster these offerings, the subway or "Metro" remains open until 3 A.M. on the weekend. While not perfect, the Metro is rather expansive and can get you within walking distance of most developed sections of the city. 

Along with everything else, D.C. has a pleasant climate. The average high temperature for the year comes in at 66. The city does experience all four seasons, but the swings between hot and cold tend to be more moderate due to the proximity of the city to the ocean.

All of these things have probably continued to perpetuate the growth of Washington D.C. and this growth will likely continue into the future as the city becomes increasingly attractive for those who are starting out their professional lives.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Ending Suburban Sprawl

The American dream: go to college, get a job, move to a nice house in the suburbs. Like this.


Here is a picture of a Phoenix suburb. Houses sprawl endlessly into the desert taking up more and more space and moving further from the urban core. An even more dramatic example is this picture of suburban Los Angeles.


When will it stop? It has become extremely challenging to actually move between the suburbs and the city center. 

Suburbs are extremely inefficient and cannot continue to spread outwards from city centers. In Los Angeles, it takes 30 minutes without traffic to reach downtown from the outer edge of the city. Considering suburbs that extend outside of the city limits, commuters can often drive upwards of an hour to work each way. Not only is it annoying to spend two or more hours commuting a day, it is unnecessary. 

It seems that Americans are finally feeling fed up with the suburbs and beginning to move back to city centers. As cities grow from the center, they can offer more and better services to their residents. Living in a community like the ones pictured in these photos is becoming an unattractive venture. I hope that the trend of downtown urbanization continues over time.


Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Friday, June 7, 2013

When Cities Get Too Big

Many of the things that I talk about relate to the benefits of urbanization, and there certainly are lots of benefits. But is there a point that cities can grow so large that they become unmanageable? Cities can be efficient because they bring together all different types of people with different knowledge and skills, which allows many types of industries to flourish. My guess is that somewhere between 5 and 10 million people, cities actually start to become less efficient for the following reasons.



Diminishing Returns: As the number of people available to fill a certain function increases, each additional person adds less to the value of the function. For example, say that one out of every one million people becomes a dog whisperer. The first one or two dog whisperers in a city may provide great benefit to those who wish to have their dogs trained; however, adding say ten more dog whisperers to a city will not provide much additional benefit because they are not needed. The value of each dog whisperer declines, but the waste that they produce remains constant.

Congestion: One of the great things about cities is that they can pack lots of people into a small area by building up. However, one problem is that no matter how high into the sky buildings stretch, in order to move from one building to another, people must always go to the ground floor and then either walk, take public transportation or drive to their destination. In this layout, a theoretically unlimited number of people can live in apartments and work in their offices without feeling cramped, but nothing can truly reduce the congestion on streets. Eventually even walking short distances becomes difficult. Consider New York City where it is nearly impossible to drive, subways are always packed and it is a struggle to walk a single block without bumping into someone. This can further limit the amount of distance a person will travel and rather than being able to move about the city, a person may feel confined to the few blocks around them because of the frustration and time it takes to go anywhere else. This can actually reduce the value of the services that are too far to reach.

Disasters: The largest cities have the most to lose in cases of disaster, and misfortunate can take many forms be it hurricane, blackout, terrorist attack or snowstorm. Any of these events can cripple an area, but the largest cities have the most to lose. While a blackout in a small town may simply encourage residents to sit in their homes and light candles, I can recall the massive New York City blackout from several years ago. The streets flooded with people and cars and everyone became stuck everywhere. Nobody could move and the city was full of panic. It was a complete mess. Situations like this can strongly interrupt the flow of life in large cities.

I remain a strong advocate of urbanization because I think that in most cases the benefits outweigh the costs. But in the modern era where cities have the resources to expand upwards of 5 to 10 million people, we must create new ways to attack these problems. The way that cities are currently designed, they have limits. In order to push the population limit higher, cities will need to plan some new and creative solutions.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Living in the BosWash

I have taken on an interest in learning about the emerging mega-regions in the country. The one that fascinates me the most is the one that I happen to live in, BosWash. This area extends from the northern suburbs of Boston all the way down the east coast to the southern end of the Washington D.C. metropolitan area. Currently, this region is home to over 50 million people, close to 20% of the population of the United States. The average population density here is many times higher than the national average. There are hardly any exurbs here; a near continuous spread of cities emerges North-South.


This image shows the mega-region in the year 2030. The deep red coloring represents heavily urbanized areas and is not far from what is present today.

Growing up I never realized how unique it was to live in an area like this. It is impossible to drive through Massachusetts without leaving an organized municipality. What Massachusetts natives think of as small towns typically have at least 10,000 residents. I realized on a trip to upstate New York that it is actually possible to hit the end of one town without entering another. This concept seemed absurd to someone living so close to the urban core.

Today each of the primary cities within this region are culturally similar to one another. Boston, New York, Philadelphia and Washington D.C. are all dense, liberal and expensive cities fully of young people. Eventually though, I think that these cities may begin to plan together on a regional scale. Already existant is the country's fastest train, Acela that runs from Boston to Washington. The population density and purchasing power of this area can allow for some spectacular projects in the future.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

United States High Speed Train?

For decades the United States has been toying with the idea of building a network of high speed train routes throughout the country. This system would be similar to the one that operates in Europe. Many oppose the system because of the cost to build it; however, I feel that some of the most innovative and economically useful public projects have also come at costs that seemed high at first. Consider for example the interstate highway system. This project began in the 1950's and parts are still under construction today; it was expensive, but it helped bring the United States to a position of power among world economies.

Here is a proposed map of the train network in the United States.

Although this map is visually appealing, it may not be fully realistic. Many areas along the red and blue routes would need to be eliminated because these areas do not have the population density to support ridership. 

A network of high speed trains would serve a wonderful need in society. Trips that are between 100 and 600 miles would be ideal to make by train. These trips would be too long many people to tolerate in a car, but going through security for a flight of this distance could take as long as the flight itself. Trains would provide high speeds without needing to wait in extensive check in lines. This could revolutionize medium-distance travel in the United States, encouraging an increase in business and leisure travel, particularly in mega-regions such as the Northeast or South-Central California. 

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, June 3, 2013

Why Does the Mass-Pike Avoid Worcester?

Mass-Pike Does Not Service Worcester

A problem that seems to come up time and time again for residents of central Massachusetts is why when building the Massachusetts Turnpike did construction avoid Worcester? Being that Worcester is the second largest city in the state, one might assume that the primary highway in the state would cut through Worcester. However, when looking at this map, the Mass-Pike shown in red dips south just east of Worcester.


One reason for the strange turn in the road may be simply economic. It is said that the construction of the highway was to run extremely over budget and that the amount of property that would need to be reclaimed in Worcester would outweigh the benefits. Simply, the increase in tax revenue that Worcester could expect from a location on the turnpike would not offset the cost to pay property owners to relinquish their lands. This seems reasonable, but the highway does go straight into downtown Boston, so it seems unlikely that this problem was not present there as well.

Another possibility is a bit more interesting. In the 1950's when construction was set to begin, Worcester had reached it's peak as an industrial powerhouse city; it's then population of more than 200,000 later declined by about 25%. Boston officials were worried about the growing importance of Worcester and thought that the city may eventually outperform Boston. One way to deal with this problem would be to suffocate Worcester by making it difficult for goods to be transported to and from the city by road. The solution: make sure that the main highway in the state did not pass through the city.

Which seems more likely?

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, June 2, 2013

Decoding the American Interstate System

I have realized that a lot of people are confused about the way that highways work in the United States. Many people seem to think that interstates are given numbers at random, but this is actually not the case. Understanding the way that interstate numbers work can actually be extremely helpful. For example, if you are lost on a long road-trip, knowing what number interstate you are on can give you great hints about where you might be! I will give some basic guidelines to help understand the way that interstates are numbered.

Trans-National Interstates Have Two Digits: The longest interstates in the country have two numbers, i.e. I-90, I-15, I-80. Numbers increase from south to north and from west to east. In the Northeast, you are likely to be travelling on I-90 or I-95 while in the Southwest you are probably going to use I-10 or I-15.

North-South Highways End in Odd Numbers: If you are travelling on an interstate that ends in an even number, you know that you are moving north or south. Interstates that are divisible by 5 are major arterites; this means that you are most likely heading for a major city.

East-West Highways End in Even Numbers: If your interstate ends in an even number, you know that you are travelling east or west.

Three Digit Interstates Pass Through Cities: If an interstate has three digits, it is short and serves a specific metropolitan area. The second two digits are the same as the two digit interstate that the route separates from. For example, I-495 would be connected to I-95. If the first digit is even, the route is a beltway, meaning that it separates from the original highway and later rejoins it. If the first digit is odd, it is a spur route which leaves separates form the original highway and does not reconnect to it.

Exit Numbers Increase From The South or West: If you are travelling on an East-West interstate, the lowest exit number will be found at the western border of a state while when traveling North-South, the lowest exit number is at the souther border of a state.

Now for a question to test your understanding. If you are at the interchange of I-10 and I-95, where are you most likely to be?

A. Denver, Colorado
B. Jacksonville, Florida
C. Los Angeles, California
D. Boston, Massachusetts

If you chose Jacksonville you are correct! Having an understanding of these rules can help to increase your sense of direction when driving in unfamiliar areas and also have a better idea of which routes to take over long-distances.




Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, June 1, 2013

The Great American Political Divide: Urban vs. Rural

Throughout most of the democratic world, elections results tend to split around regional differences. Historically this is true of the United States as well. Think back to the American Civil War. In presidential election of 1860 that preceded the war, the country split almost perfectly along a north south divide. The following map illustrates the stark divide in politics between north and south.


However, over the last 20-30 years in the United States, this long-standing pattern has begun to unravel. With each passing year, the dividing line between Democrats and Republicans has shifted more and more from a regional separation to one of urban vs. rural. Cities have increasingly swung Democratic while rural areas have become Republican strongholds. It seems that population density is becoming one of the biggest indicators of voting preference.

Take of example this map of midterm election results for 2010. Notice that most of the country looks strongly red; the Republican party controls a strong majority of the physical land area.



Notice also that this map is very different from the first. There seems to be few regional splits in voting preferences. Blue and red areas are largely intermixed throughout the country.

But now look at this third map. This shows the same results as the last map, but now the sizes of the districts have been changed to show them in proportion to their population. This image is barely recognizable as the United States. Notice how tiny the huge swath of red districts has become in comparison to the now prominent blue, Democrat controlled districts. You can clearly see Cape Cod, Long Island and the San Francisco Bay Area all colored blue. 


These blue areas almost exclusively represent densely populated urban areas. When looking at this map, the country looks much more evenly split. In the last election in 2012, 27 of the 30 largest urban areas in the country voted Democratic in the presidential election. 

If this trend continues with urbanization, the future of the Republican party as we know it may be uncertain. 


Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,