Monday, July 22, 2013

Dealing with Shrinking Cities

Defending What's Left of Declining Cities

Despite the fact that we like to imagine that over time cities always become larger and more prosperous this is not always the case. In the United States an entire region of cities has been declining in prestige and population for about 50 years. This area is the upper midwest and is known as the Rust Belt. Cities such as Detroit (more on that later), St. Louis, Youngstown and Flint have been shrinking for decades. Public officials have either turned a blind eye or just hoped that trends would reverse. As these areas lost manufacturing jobs that were at the base of the economy, they have been forced to cut back.

I wanted to show you a picture of Detroit specifically. It is the highlight of urban decline and it's population has dropped from a peak of 1.8 million to around 700,000.


This is only one neighborhood, but it is largely representative of the whole city. Notice that a once full residential neighborhood stands with fewer than 50% of the houses remaining. This problem plagues Detroit. The city has a large size but because residents are so dispersed and density is low, city services are strained.

But what do we do?

1. Accept Shrink

The first step to fixing any problem is always acknowledging that it exists. Clearly some cities have a dramatic shrinking problem. Often times, city boundaries were created large to accommodate high density population; it makes sense that if it was known that the population would shrink, the city would have been designed smaller.

2. Centralize  

This could be a challenge. I propose literally moving people out of the abandoned reaches and into the urban core. This will do two things. First, it will allow the city to cut services to outlying areas because they will truly be abandoned. Secondly, increased density in a central urban area will make the city FEEL bigger. This can help residents to cope and may restore some faith in the community. Bringing people together may also increase business activity in the central core of the city.

3. Defend What's Left

Rather than continuing to reduce the size of the central core, revitalize downtown and make the city more livable. Make the center of a city that people want to come to and want to stay in. Rebuilding downtown and bringing a in new businesses will bolster the economy and hopefully help to stop the exodus. If this does not happen, the city will probably keep shrinking!

It is certainly not easy to deal with a shrinking city and by no means is shrink the "fault" of urban designers. Many factors relate to why people may want to leave a city. It sometimes takes radical and creative approaches to turn things around. My next post will be about Detroit and it's specific dilemna.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Friday, June 7, 2013

When Cities Get Too Big

Many of the things that I talk about relate to the benefits of urbanization, and there certainly are lots of benefits. But is there a point that cities can grow so large that they become unmanageable? Cities can be efficient because they bring together all different types of people with different knowledge and skills, which allows many types of industries to flourish. My guess is that somewhere between 5 and 10 million people, cities actually start to become less efficient for the following reasons.



Diminishing Returns: As the number of people available to fill a certain function increases, each additional person adds less to the value of the function. For example, say that one out of every one million people becomes a dog whisperer. The first one or two dog whisperers in a city may provide great benefit to those who wish to have their dogs trained; however, adding say ten more dog whisperers to a city will not provide much additional benefit because they are not needed. The value of each dog whisperer declines, but the waste that they produce remains constant.

Congestion: One of the great things about cities is that they can pack lots of people into a small area by building up. However, one problem is that no matter how high into the sky buildings stretch, in order to move from one building to another, people must always go to the ground floor and then either walk, take public transportation or drive to their destination. In this layout, a theoretically unlimited number of people can live in apartments and work in their offices without feeling cramped, but nothing can truly reduce the congestion on streets. Eventually even walking short distances becomes difficult. Consider New York City where it is nearly impossible to drive, subways are always packed and it is a struggle to walk a single block without bumping into someone. This can further limit the amount of distance a person will travel and rather than being able to move about the city, a person may feel confined to the few blocks around them because of the frustration and time it takes to go anywhere else. This can actually reduce the value of the services that are too far to reach.

Disasters: The largest cities have the most to lose in cases of disaster, and misfortunate can take many forms be it hurricane, blackout, terrorist attack or snowstorm. Any of these events can cripple an area, but the largest cities have the most to lose. While a blackout in a small town may simply encourage residents to sit in their homes and light candles, I can recall the massive New York City blackout from several years ago. The streets flooded with people and cars and everyone became stuck everywhere. Nobody could move and the city was full of panic. It was a complete mess. Situations like this can strongly interrupt the flow of life in large cities.

I remain a strong advocate of urbanization because I think that in most cases the benefits outweigh the costs. But in the modern era where cities have the resources to expand upwards of 5 to 10 million people, we must create new ways to attack these problems. The way that cities are currently designed, they have limits. In order to push the population limit higher, cities will need to plan some new and creative solutions.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,