Tuesday, September 24, 2013

Paying People not to Drive

Using Money to Get Cars Off the Roads

I recently wrote a post about traffic congestion and how small decreases in driving levels can lead to huge reductions in traffic. A study had found that even when given the option to take public transportation to work and that even when it would be cheaper and result in less travel time, Americans prefer to travel by car. Instead of just hoping that people would get off the roads, the government could step in and start paying people not to.


Yes I'm talking about a government subsidy. Before you write me off as crazy I would like to remind you that the government subsidizes all types of things, such as not to grow crops.

If we could reduce driving by even 5% during rush hour, commutes would be much more pleasant for the other 95%. I believe that the best way to go about a program like this is to develop a contract of some sort where a driver agrees to take public transportation in a city say 1 day per week and on that day not drive and in exchange the city could pay for the cost of his or her transportation. One caveat is that this program could only work in very dense cities with good transportation networks such as New York, Boston, Chicago and San Francisco.

I have a budget plan as well. This program would not be free and I do not advocate increasing the deficit. I think that in cities that enact this program they should also create a density gas tax. Gas stations would be charged a gas tax in proportion to the density of the area. The tax would be highest in the densest areas because it is in these areas that public transportation usage would help the most and therefore those who do choose to drive and fill up in these areas would have to pay extra. In return this money would go into a fund to pay for the public transportation subsidy.

My plan may be radical, but I bet it would make everyone's days go a bit smoother and faster on the roads. 

Labels: , , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, July 3, 2013

Improving The Driving Experience: Dynamic Parking and Driving

Yesterday I was watching a video about new innovations that will likely come to the car industry over the next 20 years. Most of the new ideas focused on cars themselves but my two favorite takeaways were actually about the driving experience as opposed to the physical car. Some cities like San Francisco have begun experimenting with what is known as dynamic parking and driving, bringing economic theory to life for drivers in congested areas.

Dynamic parking is essentially supply and demand brought to life in real time. Have you ever spent an hour driving around a city looking for a parking spot? Well no more. Really. In San Francisco, as parking spaces get taken, the prices of other meters increase continuously up to a current $6 dollar per hour cap. As prices rise higher, people are less likely to want to pay to park, but for those who really need a spot and are willing to pay, spots will be available. Once the program finishes the pilot phase, the maximum cap will likely be removed from the meters so that the system can work even more efficiently.

Learn more about this map and San Francisco parking here.


The second thing that I like even more than dynamic parking has a variety of names but for purposes of consistency I will call it dynamic driving. Picture a crowded four lane highway with cars stuck in every lane for hours trying to get to work, school or wherever. Now imagine cars cruising at non-traffic speeds through one of these lanes. This is dynamic driving. Much like getting a fast pass at an amusement park, drivers can opt to pay a price to drive in the traffic free lane. Depending on how congested the other lanes are, this price will fluctuate to ensure that the traffic free lane really remains traffic free. This will allow people the option to choose to pay to remove the inconvenience of traffic which is a remarkably new idea.

Both dynamic parking and driving new ideas but they come with great benefits. They can boost government revenues both at local and federal levels as people pay directly for the convenience of using roads and parking spaces. Despite the increased revenues for the government and overall efficiency gains, consumers have the option to keep their current habits; if you don't want to pay, you can stay in traffic just as you always have. There seem to be few if any downsides to these new programs and other cities will soon likely follow San Francisco in adopting these new innovative traffic control measures.

Despite all of these innovations, car use may be on the permanent decline. 

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , ,